We found this link to good and bad insurance companies. Although we have found this not a 100% accorate. There are some tough ones on this list. It is from https://www.badfaithinsurance.org/indexdetaillist.html. State Farm we have found to be Good/Fair with Homeowners claims.
HALL OF SHAME CLAIMS DENIED RANKING * BAD-FAITH PRACTICES * Rank #1 = THE WORST (#) = Footnote # |
HALL OF FAME CLAIMS PAID RANKING * GOOD-FAITH PRACTICES * Rank #1 = THE BEST (#) = Footnote # |
||
Rank | Bad-Faith Insurers * | Rank | Good-Faith Insurers * |
1. | The Hartford (5) (DO NOT BUY) | 1. | Amica (23) (BEST TO BUY) |
2. | Allstate (6) (DO NOT BUY) | 1. | Chubb (20) (BEST TO BUY) |
2. | State Farm (7) (DO NOT BUY) | 3. | Allianz (19) (BEST TO BUY) |
4. | Unum (Disability, LTC, Life)(35) | 4. | Coventry Health (64) |
5. | CIGNA Health (52) | 5. | Kaiser Permanente (69) |
6. | Berkshire Hathaway (NICO)(16) | 6. | Credit Suisse (27) |
7. | CNA (33) | 7. | Royal & Sun Alliance (36) |
8. | Assurant Health (54) | 8. | GMAC (37) |
9. | ACE Re (68) | 9. | Swiss Re America (47) |
10. | American Family (31) | 10. | Fairfax Financial (39) |
11. | Liberty Mutual (8) | 11. | Electric Mutual (26) |
12. | Unitrin (46) | 12. | Aetna Health (21) |
13. | Zurich (9a) / Farmers (9) | 13. | Cuna Mutual (41) |
14. | Nationwide (11) | 14. | Quincy Mutual (43) |
15. | Metlife (30) | 15. | New York Life (78) |
16. | Mercury General (34) | 16. | No. Carolina Farm Bureau 44 |
17. | Conseco (38) | 17. | John Hancock (40) |
18. | Auto-Owners (48) | 18. | Humana Health (42) |
19. | Progressive (10) | 19. | Iowa Farm Bureau (49) |
20. | GEICO (16) | 20. | Idaho Farm Bureau (50) |
21. | Wellpoint Health (28) | 21. | St. Paul Companies (15) |
22. | Prudential (32) | 22. | Norfolk & Dedham (53) |
23. | Safeco (13) | 23. | USAA (18) |
24. | State Auto (22) | 24. | United Fire & Casualty (56) |
25. | California State Auto (59) | 25. | Federated Mutual (58) |
26. | UnitedHealth (55) | 26. | Oregon Mutual (60) |
27. | Torchmark (105) | 27. | Selective (62) |
28. | Blue Cross Blue Shield (104) | 28. | Horace Mann (103) |
29. | Grange (71) | 29. | Mass Mutual (66) |
30. | Interins Exchange Auto (87) | 30. | White Mountains (24) |
31. | Sentry (67) | 31. | Kentucky Farm Bureau (70) |
32. | Harleysville (75) | 32. | EMC (72) |
33. | AIG (12) | 33. | Lititz Mutual (74) |
34. | Markel (73) | 34. | Commerce (76) |
35. | American Financial (14) | 35. | Philadelphia United (80) |
36. | Bristol West (88) | 36. | Mutual Of Enumclaw (82) |
37. | Allmerica Financial (79) | 37. | Greater New York (84) |
38. | Pennsylvania National (81) | 38. | Franklin Mutual (86) |
39. | National Grange Mutual (83) | 39. | Country Companies (90) |
40. | Shelter (61) | 40. | Travelers (29) |
41. | Tennessee Farmers (57) | 41. | Michigan Farm Bureau (102) |
42. | Mutual Benefit (89) | 42. | Concord (92) |
43. | Ohio Casualty (65) | 43. | Amerisure (100) |
44. | California Casualty (93) | 44. | Alfa (96) |
45. | Central Companies (95) | 45. | RLI (98) |
46. | Penn America (97) | 46. | United National (101) |
47. | Penn Miller (99) | 47. | Farm Bureau (Indiana) (17) |
48. | Health Net (106) | 48. | Southern Farm Bureau (77) |
49. | Balboa (85) | 49. | Georgia Farm Bureau (94) |
50. | Ace USA (68) | 50. | Erie (45 |
HALL OF SHAME CLAIMS DENIED RANKING * BAD-FAITH PRACTICES * Rank #1 = THE WORST (#) = Footnote # |
HALL OF FAME CLAIMS PAID RANKING * GOOD-FAITH PRACTICES * Rank #1 = THE BEST (#) = Footnote # |
||
Rank | Bad-Faith Insurers * | Rank | Good-Faith Insurers * |
1. | The Hartford (5) (DO NOT BUY) | 1. | Amica (23) (BEST TO BUY) |
2. | Allstate (6) (DO NOT BUY) | 1. | Chubb (20) (BEST TO BUY) |
2. | State Farm (7) (DO NOT BUY) | 3. | Allianz (19) (BEST TO BUY) |
4. | Unum (Disability, LTC, Life)(35) | 4. | Coventry Health (64) |
5. | CIGNA Health (52) | 5. | Kaiser Permanente (69) |
6. | Berkshire Hathaway (NICO)(16) | 6. | Credit Suisse (27) |
7. | CNA (33) | 7. | Royal & Sun Alliance (36) |
8. | Assurant Health (54) | 8. | GMAC (37) |
9. | ACE Re (68) | 9. | Swiss Re America (47) |
10. | American Family (31) | 10. | Fairfax Financial (39) |
11. | Liberty Mutual (8) | 11. | Electric Mutual (26) |
12. | Unitrin (46) | 12. | Aetna Health (21) |
13. | Zurich (9a) / Farmers (9) | 13. | Cuna Mutual (41) |
14. | Nationwide (11) | 14. | Quincy Mutual (43) |
15. | Metlife (30) | 15. | New York Life (78) |
16. | Mercury General (34) | 16. | No. Carolina Farm Bureau 44 |
17. | Conseco (38) | 17. | John Hancock (40) |
18. | Auto-Owners (48) | 18. | Humana Health (42) |
19. | Progressive (10) | 19. | Iowa Farm Bureau (49) |
20. | GEICO (16) | 20. | Idaho Farm Bureau (50) |
21. | Wellpoint Health (28) | 21. | St. Paul Companies (15) |
22. | Prudential (32) | 22. | Norfolk & Dedham (53) |
23. | Safeco (13) | 23. | USAA (18) |
24. | State Auto (22) | 24. | United Fire & Casualty (56) |
25. | California State Auto (59) | 25. | Federated Mutual (58) |
26. | UnitedHealth (55) | 26. | Oregon Mutual (60) |
27. | Torchmark (105) | 27. | Selective (62) |
28. | Blue Cross Blue Shield (104) | 28. | Horace Mann (103) |
29. | Grange (71) | 29. | Mass Mutual (66) |
30. | Interins Exchange Auto (87) | 30. | White Mountains (24) |
31. | Sentry (67) | 31. | Kentucky Farm Bureau (70) |
32. | Harleysville (75) | 32. | EMC (72) |
33. | AIG (12) | 33. | Lititz Mutual (74) |
34. | Markel (73) | 34. | Commerce (76) |
35. | American Financial (14) | 35. | Philadelphia United (80) |
36. | Bristol West (88) | 36. | Mutual Of Enumclaw (82) |
37. | Allmerica Financial (79) | 37. | Greater New York (84) |
38. | Pennsylvania National (81) | 38. | Franklin Mutual (86) |
39. | National Grange Mutual (83) | 39. | Country Companies (90) |
40. | Shelter (61) | 40. | Travelers (29) |
41. | Tennessee Farmers (57) | 41. | Michigan Farm Bureau (102) |
42. | Mutual Benefit (89) | 42. | Concord (92) |
43. | Ohio Casualty (65) | 43. | Amerisure (100) |
44. | California Casualty (93) | 44. | Alfa (96) |
45. | Central Companies (95) | 45. | RLI (98) |
46. | Penn America (97) | 46. | United National (101) |
47. | Penn Miller (99) | 47. | Farm Bureau (Indiana) (17) |
48. | Health Net (106) | 48. | Southern Farm Bureau (77) |
49. | Balboa (85) | 49. | Georgia Farm Bureau (94) |
50. | Ace USA (68) | 50. | Erie (45 |